Skip to Content (Press Enter)
Skip to Footer (Press Enter)

Karen's Hallmark Shop
Get 2 for $22 on select Hallmark gifts. Shop the sale
Send unlimited eCards as a Hallmark+ member. Join Hallmark+
Shop more ways to save and show them you care. See all offers

Baptism & Christening Gifts

My Friend Jesus Stuffed Doll, 13"

My Friend Jesus Stuffed Doll, 13"

$16.99
5.0 (700)
Mud Pie Gold Cross Pearl Bracelet for Toddler

Mud Pie Gold Cross Pearl Bracelet for Toddler

$25.00
Bless You, Little One Board Book

Bless You, Little One Board Book

$12.99
5.0 (4)
Noah's Ark and Animals Plush Playset, 7 Pieces

Noah's Ark and Animals Plush Playset, 7 Pieces

$34.99
5.0 (84)
God Made You Wonderful Recordable Storybook

God Made You Wonderful Recordable Storybook

$34.99
5.0 (40)
Baby Lamb Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

Baby Lamb Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

$18.99
5.0 (134)
Better Together Lion and Lamb Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25"

Better Together Lion and Lamb Magnetic Plush Pair, 5.25"

$16.99
5.0 (1)
Noah Builds an Ark Plush Cloth Baby Book

Noah Builds an Ark Plush Cloth Baby Book

$16.99
5.0 (1)
Mud Pie Cross Jewelry Gift Set for Baby

Mud Pie Cross Jewelry Gift Set for Baby

$32.00
Precious Moments® Jesus Loves Me Cross for Girl

Precious Moments® Jesus Loves Me Cross for Girl

$26.99
5.0 (54)
Precious Moments Jesus Loves Me Cross for Boy

Precious Moments Jesus Loves Me Cross for Boy

$26.99
5.0 (48)
My Friend Jesus Mini Plush Doll, 8"

My Friend Jesus Mini Plush Doll, 8"

$12.99
4.5 (6)
Noah's Ark Play Time Gift Set

Noah's Ark Play Time Gift Set

From $29.99 - to $64.98
Little Lamb Musical Snow Globe

Little Lamb Musical Snow Globe

$34.99
5.0 (69)
The Lion and The Lamb: A Touch & Feel Book About God's Love Cloth Book

The Lion and The Lamb: A Touch & Feel Book About God's Love Cloth Book

$16.99
5.0 (21)
DaySpring I Am Held Comfort Cross, 2.25"

DaySpring I Am Held Comfort Cross, 2.25"

$7.99
Good Things Picture Frame, 4x6

Good Things Picture Frame, 4x6

$22.99
5.0 (5)
Amazing Grace Lullaby Bear Angel Plush With Sound

Amazing Grace Lullaby Bear Angel Plush With Sound

$29.99
5.0 (1)
Be Strong and Courageous Metal Bookmark With Cross Charm

Be Strong and Courageous Metal Bookmark With Cross Charm

$12.99
You Are Wonderfully Made Teddy Bear Plush, 8"

You Are Wonderfully Made Teddy Bear Plush, 8"

$12.99
5.0 (2)
Nighttime Prayer Pillow and Blanket Set

Nighttime Prayer Pillow and Blanket Set

$49.99
Precious Moments May God Send His Angels Baptism Picture Frame, 3x4

Precious Moments May God Send His Angels Baptism Picture Frame, 3x4

$36.99
My Baptism Mini Comfort Cross, 2.25"

My Baptism Mini Comfort Cross, 2.25"

$8.99
Lullaby Lamb Musical Stuffed Animal, 8.25"

Lullaby Lamb Musical Stuffed Animal, 8.25"

$29.99
5.0 (141)
Demdaco Guardian Angel Plush Lion, 7"

Demdaco Guardian Angel Plush Lion, 7"

$22.99
5.0 (4)
Mud Pie Silver Cross Pearl Bracelet for Toddler

Mud Pie Silver Cross Pearl Bracelet for Toddler

$25.00
Mud Pie Acrylic Picture Frame With Cross and Bible Verse, 3x4

Mud Pie Acrylic Picture Frame With Cross and Bible Verse, 3x4

$20.00
Noah's Ark 9-Piece Wood Puzzle

Noah's Ark 9-Piece Wood Puzzle

$29.99
5.0 (16)
Demdaco Ceramic Lamb Bank

Demdaco Ceramic Lamb Bank

$18.00
Jonah and the Whale 48-Piece Floor Puzzle

Jonah and the Whale 48-Piece Floor Puzzle

$19.99
Zip-Along Sheep Plush Toy

Zip-Along Sheep Plush Toy

$9.99
1.0 (1)
God's Promises for Your Life Book

God's Promises for Your Life Book

$14.99
5.0 (93)
100 Things God Loves About You Book

100 Things God Loves About You Book

$15.95
5.0 (131)
Comfort Holy Land Wood Cross

Comfort Holy Land Wood Cross

$22.99
5.0 (459)
Small Blessing Giving Bear Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

Small Blessing Giving Bear Stuffed Animal, 8.5"

$19.99
5.0 (109)
7 Days of Creation Plush Floor Play Set

7 Days of Creation Plush Floor Play Set

$34.99
Lamb Plush With Sound, 8"

Lamb Plush With Sound, 8"

$19.99
1.0 (1)
Our Faith Is Our Joy Picture Frame, 4x6

Our Faith Is Our Joy Picture Frame, 4x6

$22.99
Lion Plush With Sound, 8"

Lion Plush With Sound, 8"

$19.99
You Are a Blessing Book

You Are a Blessing Book

$14.99
5.0 (58)
Demdaco Guardian Angel Plush Lamb, 7"

Demdaco Guardian Angel Plush Lamb, 7"

$22.99
5.0 (8)
Roman Prayer Changes Everything Locket Bracelet

Roman Prayer Changes Everything Locket Bracelet

$14.00
5.0 (1)
Demdaco Jesus Loves Me Musical Lullaby Lamb Stuffed Animal, 18"

Demdaco Jesus Loves Me Musical Lullaby Lamb Stuffed Animal, 18"

$35.99
You’ve seen 43 of 43 products
Loading