Skip to Content (Press Enter)
Skip to Footer (Press Enter)

My store

Karen's Hallmark Shop
Get 2 for $22 on select Hallmark gifts. Shop the sale
Get it by Mother’s Day: Order by May 3. Shipping details
Hurry! 20% off graduation photo cards ends May 3. Shop now

Magic Keepsake Ornaments

What are you shopping for?

  • $0.00 - $14.99
Mini Painted Bunting Ornament, 0.75"
Keepsake |

Mini Painted Bunting Ornament, 0.75"

$9.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Miniature

Mini Bitty Bright Butterfly Metal Ornament, 1.25"
Keepsake |

Mini Bitty Bright Butterfly Metal Ornament, 1.25"

$10.99
2
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Miniature

Fairy Messengers Gladiolus Fairy Ornament
Keepsake |

Fairy Messengers Gladiolus Fairy Ornament

$14.99

Continuing Series

Mini Morning Glory Fairy Ornament, 1"
Keepsake |

Mini Morning Glory Fairy Ornament, 1"

$9.99
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Miniature

MLB Los Angeles Dodgers™ World Series Champions™ 2024 Ornament
Keepsake |

MLB Los Angeles Dodgers™ World Series Champions™ 2024 Ornament

$12.49 Was $24.99 , is
SALE
Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Dr. Finkelstein's Lab Tree Topper Replacement Remote Control
Keepsake |

Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Dr. Finkelstein's Lab Tree Topper Replacement Remote Control

$5.99
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets™ Collection Tree Topper Replacement Remote Control
Keepsake |

Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets™ Collection Tree Topper Replacement Remote Control

$5.99
NHL Florida Panthers™ 2024 Stanley Cup® Champions Hockey Ornament
Keepsake |

NHL Florida Panthers™ 2024 Stanley Cup® Champions Hockey Ornament

$12.49 Was $24.99 , is
SALE
Keepsake Power Cord (Required for Storytellers)
Keepsake |

Keepsake Power Cord (Required for Storytellers)

$14.99
811
4.5 of 5 Customer Rating
Brass Ornament Hooks, Set of 20
Keepsake |

Brass Ornament Hooks, Set of 20

$3.99
794
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Mini Brass Ornament Hooks, Set of 25
Keepsake |

Mini Brass Ornament Hooks, Set of 25

$3.99
630
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating
Minecraft Enderman Ornament
Keepsake |

Minecraft Enderman Ornament

$14.24 Was $18.99 , is
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Online only

SALE
Minecraft The Nether Ornament
Keepsake |

Minecraft The Nether Ornament

$14.24 Was $18.99 , is
4
4.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Online only

SALE
Pokémon Charizard Ornament
Keepsake |

Pokémon Charizard Ornament

$13.49 Was $17.99 , is
8
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Online only

SALE
Nintendo Animal Crossing™: New Horizons K.K. Musical Ornament
Keepsake |

Nintendo Animal Crossing™: New Horizons K.K. Musical Ornament

$14.99 Was $19.99 , is
1
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Online only

SALE
Disney Hocus Pocus Winifred Sanderson Ornament
Keepsake |

Disney Hocus Pocus Winifred Sanderson Ornament

$14.99 Was $19.99 , is
22
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Online only

SALE
Disney Hocus Pocus Mary Sanderson Ornament
Keepsake |

Disney Hocus Pocus Mary Sanderson Ornament

$14.99 Was $19.99 , is
31
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Online only

SALE
Disney Hocus Pocus Sarah Sanderson Ornament
Keepsake |

Disney Hocus Pocus Sarah Sanderson Ornament

$14.99 Was $19.99 , is
51
5.0 of 5 Customer Rating

Online only

SALE
You’ve seen 18 of 18 products
Loading